Unit4AViewofMountainsJonathanSchell1.OnAugust9,1945,thedaytheatomicbombwasdroppedonNagasaki,YosukeYamahata,aphotographerservingintheJapanesearmy,wasdispatchedtothedestroyedcity.Thehundredorsopictureshetookthenextdayconstitutethefullestphotographicrecordofnucleardestructioninexistence.Hiroshima,destroyedthreedaysearlier,hadlargelyescapedthecamera'slensinthefirstdayafterthebombing.ItwasthereforelefttoYamahatatorecord,methodically-and,asithappens,withagreatandsimpleartistry–theeffectsonahumanpopulationofanuclearweapononlyhoursafterithadbeenused.SomeofYamahata'spicturesshowcorpsescharredinthepeculiarwayinwhichanuclearfireballcharsitsvictims.Theyhavebeenburnedbylight–technicallyspeaking,bythe“thermalpulse”-andtheirbodiesareoftenbrandedwiththepatternsoftheirclothes,whosecolorsabsorblightindifferentdegrees.Onephotographshowsahorsetwistedunderthecartithadbeenpulling.Anothershowsaheapofsomethingthatoncehadbeenahumanbeinghangingoveraledgeintoaditch.Athirdshowsagirlwhohassomehowsurvivedunwoundedstandingintheopenmouthofabombshelterandsmilinganunearthlysmile,shockinguswiththesightofordinarylife,whichotherwiseseemstohavebeenleftbehindforgoodinthesceneswearewitnessing.Stretchingintothedistanceonallsidesarefieldsofrubbledottedwithfires,and,inthebackground,aviewofmountains.Wecanseethemountainsbecausethecityisgone.Thatabsence,evenmorethanwreckage,containstheheartofthematter.Thetruemeasureoftheeventliesnotinwhatremainsbutinallthathasdisappeared.2.IttookafewsecondsfortheUnitedStatestodestroyNagasakiwiththeworld'ssecondatomicbomb,butittookfiftyyearsforYamahata'spicturesoftheeventtomakethejourneybackfromNagasakitotheUnitedStates.Theywereshownforthefirsttimeinthiscountryin1995,attheInternationalCenterforPhotographyinNewYork.Arrivingahalf-centurylate,theyarestillnews.Thephotographsdisplaythefateofasinglecity,buttheirmeaningisuniversal,since,inourageofnucleararms,whathappenedtoNagasakiNagasakiphotographs,theInworld.theincityanytohappenflash,aincan,comesintoitsown.NagasakihasalwaysbeenintheshadowofHiroshima,asifthehumanimaginationhadstumbledtoexhaustioninthewreckageofthefirstruinedcitywithoutreachingeventheoutskirtsofthe second. Yet the
bombi ng of Nagasaki i s i n certai n respects the fi tter symbol of the nucl ear
danger that sti l l hangs over us. It i s proof that, havi ng once used nucl ear
weapons, we can use them agai n. It i nt roduces the i dea of a seri es - the
seri es
that, wi th tens of thousands of nucl ear weapons remai ni ng i n exi stence,
cont i nues to threaten everyone. (The unpredi ctabl e, open-ended character of
the seri es i s suggested by the fact that the second bomb ori gi nal l y was to
be dropped on the ci ty of Kokura, whi ch was spared Nagasaki ' s fate onl y
because
bad weather protected i t from vi ew. ) Each pi cture therefore seemed not so
much
an i mage of somethi ng that happened a hal f -century ago as a wi ndow cut i nto
the wal l of the photography center showi ng what soon coul d easi l y happen to
New York. Wherever the exhi bi t mi ght t ravel , moreover, the vi ew of threatened
future from these “wi ndows” woul d be roughl y accurate, si nce, al though every
i ntact ci ty i s di fferent from every other, al l ci ti es that suffer nucl ear
dest ruct i on wi l l l ook much the same.
3.
Yamahata' s pi ctures afford a gl i mpse of the end of the worl d. Yet i n our
day, when the chal l enge i s not j ust to apprehend the nucl ear peri l but to sei ze
a God-gi ven opportuni ty to di spel i t once and for al l , we seem to need, i n
addi t i on, some other pi cture to counterpoi se agai nst rui ned Nagasaki - one
showi ng not what we woul d l ose through our fai l ure but what we woul d gai n by
our success. What mi ght that pi cture be, though How do you show the
opposi te
of the end of the worl d Shoul d i t be Nagasaki , i ntact and al i ve, before the
bomb was dropped - or perhaps the spared ci ty of Kokura Shoul d i t be a
chi l d,
or a mother and chi l d, or perhaps the Earth i tsel f None seems adequate, for
how can we gi ve a defi ni te form to that whi ch can assume i nf i ni te forms,
namel y,
the l i ves of al l human bei ngs, now and i n the future Imagi nati on, faced wi th